Amish Family-Style Meal at Plain & Fancy Farm in Lancaster

Thanksgiving at Plain & Fancy Farm

Thanksgiving Dinner at Plain & Fancy Farm

Join Us for Thanksgiving

Make this Thanksgiving delicious and stress-free by letting Smokehouse at Plain & Fancy Farm do the cooking. Whether you choose to dine-in and enjoy a relaxed meal with family at Plain & Fancy Farm, or takeout and bring the flavors home, we’re serving up a hearty, holiday-inspired menu that lets you spend less time in the kitchen—and more time together.

Family-Style Dine-In Menu Details

All-Inclusive Price for 2025
$55 per adult | $27 per child (ages 4-12)
Includes non-alcoholic beverage, tax and gratuity

2026 Menu

  • Main: Roasted Turkey Breast, Beef Brisket
  • Sides: Cranberry Sauce, Rolls with Butter, Amish Macaroni Salad, Mashed Potatoes, Cornbread Stuffing, Green Beans, Sweet Potato Casserole, Honey Maple Carrots, Gravy
  • Dessert: Apple Pie, Pumpkin Pie

Non-alcoholic beverages, tax and gratuity included.

RESERVATIONS OPEN 10/7 at 10AM for 2026

CALL (717) 768-4400 to make your reservation. Reservations lines are open 10AM to 6PM daily.

Amish Family-Style Meal at Plain & Fancy Farm in Lancaster
Family at Thanksgiving with Take Home Meal

Gobbler-To-Go

Our Thanksgiving Meal for 4 to Go for $140.

Gobbler-To-Go Includes:

  • 2 Pounds of Oven Roasted Turkey Breast
  • 2 Pounds of Beef Brisket
  • 1 Quart of Smokehouse Cornbread Stuffing
  • 1 Quart of Mashed Potatoes
  • 1 Quart of Green Beans
  • 8 Dinner Rolls
  • 12 Ounces Cranberry Sauce
  • 1 Quart Amish Macaroni
  • 1 Quart Gravy
  • 4 Slices of Pumpkin Pie

Consider upgrading the beef brisket to Smoked Prime Rib with Au Jus with our Deluxe Gobbler-To-Go for just $50 more.

No substitutions. We recommend placing your order at least 2 weeks prior.

Call (717) 419-1337 to place your order.

Thanksgiving Commonly Asked Questions

Do I need to make reservations?

We highly recommend making reservations.

When is the last day that I can make reservations for dine-in?

We will take reservations up until 11/22 for Thanksgiving as long as there is availability.

Will your regular menu be available on Thanksgiving?

No, we will only be serving our family-style Thanksgiving menu.

Will there be dark meat turkey?

No, it is white turkey breast meat.

What are your Thanksgiving hours for dine in?

Seating starts 11:30AM, last reservation is 6PM, last seating is at 7PM.

Will I be sitting with other people?

No, your party will have a private table.

Will you be serving alcohol on Thanksgiving?

Yes, we will be offer our full list of beer, wine and cocktails. Plus a few special drinks for that day. Alcoholic beverages are not included in the family-style pricing.

Is the family-style meal all-you-can-eat?

Yes, the family style meal is all-you-can-eat. Leftovers are not available to take home. You may order Gobbler-to-Go if you’d like to have some Thanksgiving leftovers.

I might not be able to make my reservations, when do I need to let you know by?

We must receive cancellations by 6PM 11/17. However, if you have an emergency, please call us and let us know.

When is the last day to order Gobbler-to-Go?

The last day to order take out “Gobbler-to-Go” is 11/22.

When is pick up time for Gobbler-to-Go?

Pick up is from 12 Noon – 6:30PM. When you reserve your meal, you will be able to select your pick-up window.

What is your cancellation policy for Gobbler-to-Go?

All orders and cancellations must be placed by 11/22.

What are the gluten-free items on the Gobbler-to-Go?

Cranberry Sauce, Roasted Turkey Breast (no gravy), Beef Brisket, Mashed Potatoes (no gravy), Green Bean Almondine, Honey Maple Carrots. Note: Sweet Potato Casserole can be made without the crumb to be gluten free, if we know in advance. Please let us know about any allergies when making your reservation.

Re-heating instructions?

All items are pick-up hot and ready to eat.

Do I have to order the full Gobbler-to-Go?

Yes, unfortunately, we can’t offer partial orders.

What if I just want a pie?

Please call Locally Made Food Shop at 717-687-6621 to place orders for Thanksgiving pies from Miller’s Bakery. They are just minutes away from us on Route 30.

What is the max party size?

Our maximum reservation size is 12 people for Thanksgiving. If you make multiple reservations, we can’t guarantee that you will be seated close to each other or in the same dining room. We will not be able to move tables in order for groups larger than 12 to sit together.

If my group is larger than 20 for Thanksgiving, can I call the group sales number?

For Thanksgiving, all reservations go through our regular reservation number. Plus note that our max reservation and table size is 12 people. However, you can have multiple reservations. We just can’t guarantee that you will be seated close to each other or in the same dining room. We will not be able to move tables in order for groups larger than 12 to sit together.

What is the minimum number of guests per reservation?

As this is family-style, it is a 2 person minimum per table with a 12 person maximum per table. If you are more than 12, you can have additional reservations but we can’t guarantee your tables will be close together and we will not be able to move tables in order for groups larger than 12 to sit together.

Exterior of Plain & Fancy Building in Lancaster PA with Smokehouse & Barn and Hearth Signs

Discover the Plain & Fancy Difference

Plain & Fancy Farm brings the best of Lancaster County together in one scenic destination. From delicious dining and award-winning lodging to Amish tours, buggy rides, and unique shopping, it’s a place where you can slow down, explore, and experience the charm of Amish Country. Whether you’re here for the day or spending the night, you’ll find everything you need to make your visit memorable—all in one beautiful location.

EXPLORE